Reported by: Steve Borecky
Videographer: Steve Borecky
Web Producer: Steve Borecky Updated: November 12, 2008 9:52am
EYEWITNESS NEWS ONLINE VIDEO C L I C K T O P L A Y
How far would you go for $40?
When Sam Juniper retired from M & G Polymers back in 2000, he had no worries about his pension plan. The book describing his health benefits said nothing would change even if the company switched insurance providers.
But following some medical tests in 2002, Juniper received a bill for $40, and was told the company's new health provider Aetna Insurance would not cover the cost of the blood work.
That began a five year court battle. After starting in Mason County Court, the dispute went all the way to the U.S. Court of Appeals in Richmond, Virginia.
Each court ruling favored Juniper, saying even though M & G changed insurance companies, the new provider should have honored the agreement in his pension plan.
"I fought it because of principle. I always thought this case was simple and I was right. I always thought I could win it, and the only way I would lose is a technicality with the courts," said Juniper
Mark Underwood handled Juniper's case pro bono and says someone had to step to the plate. "While $40 may be small in the grand scheme of things, $40 again and again for hundreds of M & G employees and their families adds up."
Juniper is still waiting for his $40 refund, but says he has no plans to cash it. Instead, he says he will buy a frame and hang it on his wall.
MORE NEWS FROM EYEWITNESS NEWS
BREAKING NEWS! WINTER WEATHER Snow And Ice Force Schools To Close Feb. 9, 2010 9:43 AM EST Schools in Kanawha and Cabell counties are closed a ...
ANOTHER BLAST OF SNOW Morning Commute Will Be Slick Feb. 9, 2010 6:41 AM EST Snow and ice are causing slick travel this morning. ...
W.Va. gov urges roof checks, new storm approaches February 09, 2010 10:26 AM As parts of West Virginia brace for more snow, Gov. Joe Manchin is urging communities to carefully inspect the roofs of schools and other public buildings.
Snow delays Dunlap jury selection February 09, 2010 9:53 AM Snowy weather has delayed the western Kentucky murder trial for a man accused of killing three children near Fort Campbell and stabbing their mother.
Ohio lawmakers work to dump driver late fees February 09, 2010 9:26 AM Ohio legislators are working on ways to end $20 fines for drivers who missed new deadlines to renew their driver licenses and vehicle registrations.
Fugitive Files
Wanted: Feb. 2, 2010 • You Can Help! First degree robbery, burglary, assault, failure to appear for court following fleeing in a vehicle while DUI, and credit card forgery.
Behind The Kitchen Door
February 4, 2010 Bob Evans-South Ridge, Los Agaves, Asian Grill, Smokey Rib House, Mr. G's Wings are on the list. Find out who has violations and who gets a big thumbs up!